Posted on August 7, 2026

Valuing And Dividing A Law Firm In An Illinois Divorce

49% of lawyers own their own law firms. Those law firms might be worth nothing. For lawyers who work in larger firms, 43% of them have equity in their firm. That equity is definitely worth something. These interests in law firms must be valued and possibly divided in an Illinois divorce.

I Want to Help You Obtain the Most Favorable Outcome Possible in Your Case.

A Law Firm Is A Business, But It Is Not Just A Business

A law firm has the potential to earn millions of dollars, employ many people, possess valuable receivables, and operate under an established name. It cannot, however, be valued exactly like a retail store, manufacturing company, or other ordinary business.

Under the Illinois Rules of Professional Conduct, “[t]he practice of law is a profession, not merely a business.” Ill. R. Prof’l Conduct (2010) R. 1.17 cmt. 1. The commentary further states that “[c]lients are not commodities that can be purchased and sold at will.” Id. These are key principles.

Yet, those principles do not mean that a law practice holds no value. Illinois Rule of Professional Conduct 1.17 expressly allows a law firm or lawyer to sell “a law practice, including good will.” Ill. R. Prof’l Conduct (2010) R. 1.17. Ordinarily, the lawyer must cease practicing in the relevant geographic area, the entire practice must be made available for sale, clients must receive written notice, and every client retains the right to hire other counsel or take possession of the file. Id.

Other professional rules impose more limitations. Typically, a law firm or lawyer “shall not share legal fees with a nonlawyer,” and a nonlawyer generally may not own an interest in a for-profit law firm. Ill. R. Prof’l Conduct (2010) R. 5.4(a), (d). 

Additionally, Illinois usually prohibits agreements that restrict an attorney’s right to practice after leaving a firm. Ill. R. Prof’l Conduct (2010) R. 5.6(a). This rule protects the attorney’s professional autonomy and “the freedom of clients to choose a lawyer.” Id. cmt. 1. 

These rules create the main difficulty in valuing a law firm during a divorce. A law firm may possess genuine economic value, but that value cannot be calculated by assuming that its attorneys, clients, referral sources, and future legal fees can be transferred freely to a hypothetical buyer.

The appraisal must determine which economic benefits belong to the firm, which depend on the continued labor of a particular lawyer, and which cannot be transferred at all.

A Law Firm Does Not Own Its Clients

Law firms often describe a client as “the firm’s client.” However, the client is still free to terminate the representation and choose a new lawyer.

Even during an authorized sale of a law practice, Rule 1.17 preserves the client’s right to retain other counsel or recover the file. Ill. R. Prof’l Conduct (2010) R. 1.17(c). Further, the Rule’s commentary explains that “[a]ll elements of client autonomy,” including the right to discharge the lawyer and transfer the representation, survive the sale. Id. cmt. 9. 

The appraiser therefore cannot assign a value to clients as if they were inventory that automatically passes to a purchaser. Rather, the appraiser must evaluate the probability that the firm’s work and revenue will continue.

This probability may depend on whether clients identify mainly with the individual lawyer or the firm, whether the relationship is recurring or transactional, whether other attorneys can keep doing the work, and whether conflicts, client consent, referral patterns, or transition systems would impact the continuation of the representation.

What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value discusses how professional practices, including law firms, depend on professional reputation and skills, referrals, client relationships, licenses, and a comparatively high concentration of intangible assets. Ronald L. Seigneur ed., What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value 10 (2017). 

Still, the existence of intangible assets does not establish that all intangibles are owned by the enterprise. A firm may benefit from its established name, institutional reputation, marketing, technology, intake procedures, or trained workforce. At the same time, an attorney may personally control the relationships that generate most of the firm’s revenue.

Imagine that a firm represents a corporation in recurring litigation through several attorneys; it may have a stronger institutional relationship than a solo lawyer hired because of that lawyer’s individual reputation. Similarly, a law firm that receives matters through an established website or a centralized intake system may have more transferable value than one whose work comes almost completely through one attorney’s personal referrals.

So, the valuation must ask why clients choose the firm, why they stay, and what is likely to happen if the attorney-owner leaves.

The Word “Partner” Does Not Establish Ownership

The title “partner” does not automatically mean that an attorney owns part of a law firm.

A firm can have equity partners, non-equity partners, income partners, contract partners, shareholders, members, associates, and attorneys serving as of counsel. Their titles may sound similar; however, their legal and economic rights differ substantially.

A non-equity partner may receive a salary without owning any of the firm’s assets. An equity partner may possess an ownership interest but lack meaningful control over compensation or firm management. Another partner may maintain a substantial capital account, own voting shares, and participate in the firm’s profits, losses, and eventual liquidation.

The appraiser must first determine what the attorney actually owns.

Depending on the firm’s governing documents, the attorney’s interest may include equity, management rights, a capital account, profit distributions, origination or deferred compensation, retirement or withdrawal benefits, unbilled work, receivables, and interests in related entities.

These kinds of rights should not be combined without analyzing what each one represents. For example, a capital account may reflect actual contributions made by the attorney. A retirement payment may function as deferred compensation instead of payment for the attorney’s equity.

The distinction also prevents double counting. If an appraiser includes a receivable as a firm asset and then capitalizes earnings that include collection of the same receivable, the same economic benefit might be valued twice. Likewise, treating a contractual retirement payment as a separate asset may duplicate value already captured in the attorney’s ownership interest.

Necessary documents may include the firm’s partnership, operating, or shareholder agreement; compensation plan; buy-sell agreement; tax returns; financial statements; capital-account records; deferred-compensation and retirement plans; and records involving prior admissions, withdrawals, retirements, and redemptions.

Law-firm valuation needs a tailored investigation. An appraiser cannot simply issue the ordinary request for business records; the document request list must be customized. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 17.

The report’s law-firm-specific checklist includes compensation formulas, origination credits, deferred-pay obligations, employment agreements, utilization reports, prior stock redemptions, former-practitioner settlements, buy-sell agreements, client concentration, fee arrangements, contingent-fee matters, accounts receivable, and work in process. Id. at 17-19. 

Without those records, an appraiser may value the attorney’s title, not the attorney’s actual ownership interest.

The Lawyer’s Compensation Is Not Necessarily The Value Of The Firm

Law-firm owners usually receive money in multiple capacities. An attorney may be compensated for performing legal work, originating clients, managing employees, supervising other lawyers, and owning an interest in the enterprise. Those economic returns must be separated.

The compensation system may assign different values to those activities. Sometimes, firms pay a percentage of fees collected from originated matters. Other times, firms allocate points for billable work, profitability, management, seniority, or firm citizenship. 

Thus, the attorney’s tax return does not necessarily show the value of the ownership interest. A Schedule K-1 may combine allocated profits, guaranteed payments, capital-account changes, and distributions. The amount distributed may differ from the amount allocated for tax purposes. Additionally, compensation may rise or fall because the firm changed its payment formula even though the business stayed the same.

The appraiser must estimate reasonable compensation for the owner’s legal and managerial work. This is because the assumption directly impacts value. Setting it too low can overstate enterprise value, but setting it too high can improperly treat firm profits as compensation for the attorney’s labor.

Attorney-compensation studies may include commingled owner profits. So, an adjustment for reasonable compensation must reflect payment for services “exclusive of profit distributions.” What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 21. The appraiser must further consider productivity because an attorney earning twice the survey amount may also be performing twice the work. Id. 

The analysis needs to examine the attorney’s hours, billing rate, collections, origination, management duties, experience, practice area, workload, and contribution to the firm rather than mechanically substituting an industry median.

Existing Property Differs From The Lawyer’s Future Earnings

Illinois law distinguishes assets existing on the valuation date from income that depends on the attorney’s future work.

In In re Marriage of Zells, the Illinois Supreme Court considered whether a lawyer’s pending contingent-fee contracts and professional goodwill could be valued and divided as marital property. The court found that “neither contingent fee contracts nor professional goodwill is subject to valuation, division or distribution as marital assets.” Zells, 143 Ill. 2d 251, 252 (1991). 

The contingent-fee contracts were too uncertain to constitute divisible property, and the court observed that an attorney has “neither the right to receive the fee” before the case is resolved “nor any assurance” that a fee will ever be received. Id. Further, the fee’s value “remains highly speculative” while the case is pending. Id. at 253. The proper context for considering fees earned in the future is the determination of income for maintenance and support. Id.

Regarding professional goodwill, the court concluded that “[g]oodwill represents merely the ability to acquire future income.” Id. at 254. Because the attorney’s income potential was already considered under the statutory property-distribution and support factors, an additional valuation of that goodwill would be “duplicative and improper.” Id. at 256. 

In re Marriage of Schneider clarified that the rule does not depend on whether the court awards maintenance or child support; rather, personal goodwill is excluded because the characteristics creating it are already considered under Section 503(d) when the court equitably divides marital property. 214 Ill. 2d 152, 166-67 (2005). So, personal goodwill cannot be included as a divisible asset simply because no maintenance award was entered. Id.

However, Schneider also stated that this restriction is “limited to personal goodwill and does not extend to enterprise goodwill.” Id. at 168. Accordingly, Zells does not establish that every law firm is worth only its physical assets. Enterprise goodwill may be considered if the evidence establishes value belonging to the firm independently of the attorney. Id. Whether such goodwill exists is a factual valuation question. 

Already-earned accounts receivable are different from contingent fees and personal goodwill, as well. Adopting the reasoning of In re Marriage of Tietz, Schneider explained that receivables are “assets that have been earned and have a known value,” even though they have not yet been collected. Id. at 169-70. The fact that payment will occur later on does not turn an earned receivable into speculative future income. Id. at 170-71. 

Overall, a law-firm valuation cannot merely project the attorney’s future earnings, capitalize that income, and characterize the result as divisible marital property. However, it may include already-earned receivables and any enterprise goodwill that is proven to exist independently of the attorney’s personal reputation, skills, and future labor.

The Appraisal Must Identify The Exact Interest And Valuation Date

After the attorney’s rights are understood, the appraisal assignment must define the property being valued.

The Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act provides that “the court shall employ a fair market value standard.” 750 ILCS 5/503(k). The valuation date is the date of trial unless the parties agree to another date or the court selects another date within its discretion. Id. Additionally, the court may seek written advice from financial experts and other professionals. 750 ILCS 5/503(l). 

The assignment should identify the law-firm entity, whether the attorney holds equity, the percentage and class of ownership, the rights and restrictions attached to that interest, the applicable valuation date, whether the firm and attorney are expected to continue their relationship, the assets and liabilities included, the treatment of compensation and deferred benefits, and the purpose of the valuation.

It’s important to remember that these questions are all connected. An attorney’s contractual payment upon immediate withdrawal may be different from the fair market value of an ongoing interest held by an attorney who intends to stay with the firm. Similarly, a valuation of the whole firm may not establish the value of one partner’s noncontrolling interest.

The final opinion must value the property the attorney truly possesses under the circumstances existing on the valuation date. If the final opinion does not do so, the appraiser may end up valuing the attorney’s job, the firm’s clients, or a hypothetical transaction that Illinois law would not allow.

Is The Law-Firm Interest Marital Or Nonmarital Property?

Before an Illinois court can divide an attorney’s interest in a law firm, it must classify the interest as marital or nonmarital property.

Section 503(a) defines “marital property” as “all property . . . acquired by either spouse subsequent to the marriage,” except for the statute’s listed categories of nonmarital property. 750 ILCS 5/503(a). Section 503(b)(1) also states that property acquired after the marriage and before the dissolution judgment “is presumed marital property,” but that presumption may be overcome through “clear and convincing evidence” that the property was acquired through one of Section 503(a)’s exceptions or under the other circumstances identified in subsection (b)(1). 750 ILCS 5/503(b)(1). 

So, an equity interest acquired during the marriage will typically be presumed marital even if only the attorney’s name appears on the ownership documents. Although Illinois Rule of Professional Conduct 5.4(d) ordinarily prevents a nonlawyer spouse from owning an interest in a for-profit law firm, that professional restriction does not create an exception to Section 503’s marital-property classification rules. It may, however, impact how the court accounts for and distributes the value of the attorney’s interest. Ill. R. Prof’l Conduct (2010) R. 5.4(d); 750 ILCS 5/503(a), (b)(1). 

Nonmarital property includes property acquired by “gift, legacy or descent” or in exchange for such property; property acquired in exchange for property owned before the marriage; property excluded by a valid agreement, including a premarital or postnuptial agreement; and, generally, property acquired before the marriage. 750 ILCS 5/503(a)(1), (2), (4), (6).

Classification should happen interest by interest. For instance, an attorney may have acquired an initial partnership interest before the marriage and bought additional equity during the marriage. The original interest and the later-acquired interest might have different classifications. Each interest must be identified, traced, classified, and valued separately.

Importantly, the acquisition date is not automatically the date the attorney started working at the firm or first was given the title of “partner.” The relevant date is when the attorney acquired the property right being valued. In other words, the employment relationship and the acquisition of ownership cannot be treated as the same event.

A Growing Law Firm Does Not Automatically Become Marital Property

A nonmarital law-firm interest does not automatically become marital just because the firm grows during the marriage.

Section 503 classifies as nonmarital “the increase in value of non-marital property,” “irrespective of whether the increase results from a contribution of marital property, non-marital property, the personal effort of a spouse, or otherwise.” 750 ILCS 5/503(a)(7). The statute makes that increase “subject to the right of reimbursement provided in subsection (c)” of Section 503. Id.; 750 ILCS 5/503(c)(2).

An attorney’s premarital ownership interest may therefore stay nonmarital even if the firm opens another office, increases its revenue, hires more lawyers, develops institutional clients, or acquires valuable enterprise goodwill later on.

In re Marriage of Werries illustrates that substantial growth during a marriage alone does not transform a nonmarital business interest into marital property; the husband’s entire 45% partnership interest, acquired partly before the marriage and partly through a gift from his father, was “clearly nonmarital property.” 247 Ill. App. 3d 639, 643 (1993). The court clarified that “[t]he issue is not the business’ form.” Id. at 646. Rather, the relevant questions are whether “there has been an actual segregation of the nonmarital estate from the marital” and whether adequate evidence separates the business from the spouses’ personal assets. Id.

Ownership, financial, tax, loan, and equity records can show whether the original interest kept its nonmarital identity. Incomplete or commingled records can instead create tracing and reimbursement disputes. The court must determine which interest appreciated, whether additional equity was acquired, what caused the increase, and whether marital property or uncompensated effort contributed to the nonmarital interest. 750 ILCS 5/503(c)(1)-(2). 

The Marital Estate May Have A Reimbursement Claim

Appreciation of a nonmarital law-firm interest remains nonmarital, but the marital estate may be entitled to reimbursement for contributions made to that interest. If one estate contributes property to another, “the contributing estate shall be reimbursed from the estate receiving the contribution.” 750 ILCS 5/503(c)(2)(A). Yet, reimbursement is unavailable for a contribution “that is not traceable by clear and convincing evidence or that was a gift.” Id. The court may order reimbursement from the marital property being divided or impose a lien against the nonmarital property. Id.

In the law-firm context, marital funds could be used to repay a buy-in loan, purchase equity, satisfy a capital call, or fund a capital account. Id.

In re Marriage of Werries applied this to a premarital business loan. A significant portion of the loan was repaid after the marriage, but the wife “never established how much the marital estate contributed to the repayment.” 247 Ill. App. 3d 639, 644 (1993). The court stated that reimbursement would have been appropriate if the claim had been established by clear and convincing evidence. Id.

Personal effort is treated separately. A spouse’s effort devoted to nonmarital property is considered a contribution from the marital estate, yet reimbursement is only available when the effort is “significant” and results in “substantial appreciation.” 750 ILCS 5/503(c)(2)(B). If the marital estate “reasonably has been compensated” for that effort, “there shall be no reimbursement.” Id.

So, an attorney’s long hours alone do not establish reimbursement. The evidence must show a connection between the attorney’s efforts and the substantial appreciation. It must also show that the marital estate was not reasonably compensated through salary, bonuses, distributions, or related benefits. In Werries, the court concluded that the appreciation was not caused by the husband’s efforts and that, “in any event, he had been reasonably compensated.” 247 Ill. App. 3d at 648. 

In all, reasonable compensation impacts both the valuation of the law firm and whether the marital estate has a reimbursement claim under Section 503(c)(2)(B).

Compensation, Distributions And Retained Earnings Are Not The Same Thing

The classification of the law-firm interest does not control every payment coming from it. Section 503(a)(8) classifies as nonmarital “income from property acquired by a method listed in paragraphs (1) through (7)” only “if the income is not attributable to the personal effort of a spouse.” 750 ILCS 5/503(a)(8). Compensation for legal services, business development, or management during the marriage must be distinguished from a passive return on nonmarital ownership. 

The firm’s label is not necessarily dispositive because salary, draws, bonuses, profit distributions, and capital-account withdrawals can represent payment for services, a return on capital, or a similar economic benefit. Additionally, tax reporting is not conclusive.

In In re Marriage of Steel, the court explained that retained earnings typically “remain the corporation’s property” and are not income to the spouse “until severed from the other corporate assets and distributed as dividends.” 2011 IL App (2d) 080974, ¶ 63. Still, retained earnings may be marital property depending mainly on the spouse’s ability to control their distribution and whether the earnings are part of the business’s value and used to fund its operations. Id.

The analysis should consider the attorney’s control over distributions, the firm’s working-capital needs, tax payments, contractual restrictions, and whether the attorney received reasonable compensation. If retained earnings are already included in the firm’s value, separately treating the same funds as another marital asset may cause double counting. Id. ¶¶ 63-69. 

Capital accounts require more than a review of the tax return. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value discusses a valuation where one expert excluded an attorney’s capital account because the partnership agreement did not allow him to take it upon departure. at 107-08. The opposing expert included it since the agreement made the funds available during his employment, and the attorney’s K-1 schedules showed that excess distributions reduced the account while undistributed income increased it. Id. The account represented a possible “present, possessory interest,” instead of a future departure benefit. Id.

Overall, compensation, retained earnings, distributions, and capital accounts should not be put into one category simply because they appear on the same tax return. The governing agreement, distribution history, K-1 schedules, and changes to the capital account should be reviewed together to understand what economic benefit the attorney truly possesses.

A Buy-Sell Agreement May Answer A Different Valuation Question

A law firm’s buy-sell, redemption, or deferred-compensation agreement may give evidence of value without necessarily establishing fair market value. Those agreements commonly calculate an owner’s payment after a specific event like disability, retirement, termination, or death. Accordingly, What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value describes the buy-sell agreement as the “road map” that governs an owner’s rights upon entry into or departure from the practice. at 74.

In In re Marriage of Gunn, the law firm’s agreement supplied a valuation formula following death, disability, retirement, or termination, yet it did not identify divorce as a triggering event, meaning that the trial court was not required to adopt the formula because “a buy/sell agreement is not necessarily an indication of fair market value.” 233 Ill. App. 3d 165, 182-84 (1992).

However, the operating agreement in In re Marriage of Schlichting explicitly addressed divorce, restricted transfers, established a valuation and buyout procedure, and permitted the nonmember spouse to contest the valuation during the divorce; the appellate court concluded that the trial court abused its discretion when it ordered a transfer that violated the agreement when the agreement “specified the valuation process in the event of a divorce.” 2014 IL App (2d) 140158, ¶¶ 68-69.

A contractual amount may therefore be persuasive, but its significance depends on whether the agreement applies to divorce, what event triggers the formula, what property or payment it measures, and whether the proposed distribution complies with its transfer restrictions. It is also recommended to evaluate current and prior agreements and determine whether they have been “tested or implemented.” What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 18.

What Makes A Law Firm Valuable?

A law firm’s value often largely depends on whether its earnings and client relationships can continue without one attorney’s constant involvement. Enterprise value is generally stronger when revenue is recurring, clients identify with the firm, several lawyers can continue the work, and the practice has well-established management, systems, technology, and a stable workforce.

Relevant factors include client and referral-source concentration, whether relationships are institutional or personal, the firm’s reputation, profitability, growth, billing practices, partner stability, and infrastructure. BVR identifies “the ongoing and future access to contacts, referral sources and clients” as an essential benefit of a transferable practice. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 13-14, 137. 

The appraiser must ultimately distinguish value belonging to the continuing enterprise from value dependent on the attorney’s personal reputation, relationships, and future labor. In Illinois, personal goodwill representing future earning capacity is not divisible marital property, while the exclusion does not necessarily extend to enterprise goodwill. See In re Marriage of Zells, 143 Ill. 2d 251, 254-56 (1991); see also In re Marriage of Schneider, 214 Ill. 2d 152, 166-68 (2005).

What Assets And Liabilities Must Be Included?

A law firm’s balance sheet may omit major assets and obligations. In response, the appraiser should consider cash, working capital, receivables, contractual rights, unbilled work, capital accounts, equipment, software, affiliated entities, and enterprise intangibles, together with debt, leases, deferred compensation, retirement or redemption obligations, taxes, client-cost advances, and malpractice claims.

Accounts receivable and work in process require a particularly higher level of scrutiny. These schedules may become a “burial ground” for uncollectible amounts, so it is important to review their aging for at least 180 days. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 18-21. Additionally, unbilled work is “an asset that should be considered as part of the valuation.” Id. Collection risk, write-offs, expenses, and associated taxes must be considered rather than valuing receivables at face value.

Unresolved contingent-fee matters must stay separate from earned receivables. The court in In re Marriage of Zells stated that pending contingent-fee contracts were not divisible marital assets, as the attorney had no present right or assurance of receiving a fee and their value remained speculative. 143 Ill. 2d 251, 252-54 (1991). 

Overall, the valuation must measure the firm’s net economic benefit. An asset should not be included without accounting for the collection costs, taxes, or contractual obligations required to realize it.

A Law Firm’s Financial Records Must Be Normalized

Tax returns and internal financial statements reflect how the firm reported its activity. Yet, they do not always demonstrate the level of economic earnings that a hypothetical buyer would expect to receive.

Normalization adjustments are meant to make the financial data “more closely reflect its true economic financial position” and operating results. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 130. The report groups those adjustments into nonoperating items, control-related adjustments, and nonrecurring or extraordinary events. Id.

Nonoperating assets and expenses should typically be separated from the firm’s normal legal operations. For example, excess cash or unrelated investments may be treated separately from operating value. Income and expenses associated with those assets should further be removed from the earnings stream used to value the practice.

Control-related adjustments address expenses or benefits that an owner can influence, such as unreasonable owner compensation, personal expenses, or unusually generous fringe benefits. The purpose is not to increase earnings automatically, but to determine what an independent operator would reasonably pay for similar facilities, services, and benefits.

Nonrecurring adjustments remove events that are not expected to continue. The BVR demonstrative report adjusted for an unusual settlement, discretionary charitable contributions, accelerated depreciation, owner insurance benefits, and the payroll-tax consequences of changing owner compensation. Seigneur ed., What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 132-33. 

The appraiser must also determine whether cash-basis records accurately represent the firm’s performance. Cash and accrual results may become similar over a long period for an established practice. Yet, cash-basis statements can be misleading when the firm is expanding rapidly, collections fluctuate, or substantial receivables and work in process are omitted. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 21. 

Reasonable owner compensation is “[o]ne of the most important adjustments” since it estimates what the firm would pay to replace the owner’s services. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 132-33. The analysis should consider the lawyer’s experience, specialty, hours, duties, management responsibilities, productivity, and rainmaking ability. Id.

Further, working capital must be evaluated. The firm needs enough funds for operations, while excess working capital may constitute a separate nonoperating asset. Insufficient capital and reliance on borrowing against “tomorrow’s collections” might increase the firm’s risk. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 14. Normalization should reflect the economic operations a hypothetical buyer would reasonably expect, not simply adding expenses back to income.

How Is A Law Firm Valued In An Illinois Divorce?

Illinois law does not have one mandatory formula for valuing a law firm. Section 503(k) requires the court to “employ a fair market value standard,” but the proper method depends on the firm, the interest being valued, and the available evidence. 750 ILCS 5/503(k). 

As stated in In re Marriage of Gunn, “[p]lacing a fair market value on the professional corporation is an art, not a science.” 233 Ill. App. 3d 165, 183 (1992). The court also provided that “[t]here is no exact formula that can be applied,” so the trial court must consider the relevant evidence and assess the experts’ credibility, the reasonableness and weight of their testimony, and their expertise in the particular area of valuation. Id.

The Asset Approach

The asset approach deducts the firm’s liabilities then values its assets. Book values may need to be adjusted to market value, while omitted assets like receivables, work in process, and identifiable intangibles may need to be added. The approach is most helpful for an asset-dependent or a winding-down practice, but asset-based methods are “rarely used for operating business enterprises and professional practices.” What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 12, 134-35. 

The Income Approach

The income approach values the economic benefits the firm is reasonably expected to generate. Capitalization of earnings may be appropriate for a “steady economic benefits stream,” whereas discounted cash flow can account for expenses, startup losses, changing growth, or unusually rapid expansion. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 12. 

Before applying a capitalization or discount rate reflecting the firm’s risks, the appraiser must normalize compensation and other financial results. Dependence on one attorney, client, referral source, or practice area may increase risk. Yet recurring revenue, institutional relationships, and a stable attorney group may reduce it. The analysis must further exclude income attributable only to the attorney’s personal future labor.

The Market Approach

The market approach compares the firm with comparable sales, partner admissions, redemptions, or prior transactions involving the firm itself. Comparability is dependent on size, location, profitability, practice area, billing arrangements, client concentration, owner involvement, and transition requirements.

In In re Marriage of Grunsten, the court stated that, although valuing a closely held corporation is subjective, the process becomes “obviously much less so” when a comparable transaction is available, “particularly when the comparison transaction involves the same property.” 304 Ill. App. 3d 12, 17 (1999). The court explained that “fair value is best measured by what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller in a voluntary transaction.” Id. 

Nevertheless, law-firm transaction data can often be anecdotal. Rules of thumb, such as revenue multiples, can be better used as reasonableness checks or benchmarks than as automatic measures of value. Any selected multiple should reflect recurring work, owner dependence, transferability, profitability, growth, client concentration, and firm infrastructure. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 12-13, 137-38. 

The Excess-Earnings Method

The excess-earnings method combines parts of the asset and income approaches to estimate intangible value. The appraiser determines normalized earnings, deducts reasonable compensation for the owner’s services and a reasonable return on the firm’s assets, and capitalizes any remaining excess earnings. What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value at 23-24. 

The result is highly sensitive to reasonable compensation, asset values, required returns, and capitalization rates; thus, this method presents a “potential for manipulation.” Id. at 12, 20. 

The rate applied to intangible excess earnings should typically exceed the blended capitalization rate for the entire firm because intangible earnings carry more risk. Id.

No approach should be selected just because it produces the highest or lowest figure. The appraiser should explain why the chosen methods fit the firm, settle differing indications, and value the attorney’s true ownership rights under Illinois’s fair-market-value standard. 750 ILCS 5/503(k). Control, marketability, and transfer restrictions should be addressed based on the governing documents and economic rights, not through an automatic discount based on the attorney’s ownership percentage alone.

How Can The Value Of A Law Firm Be Divided?

Once the marital interest is valued, the Illinois court must divide the marital estate “in just proportions” after considering all relevant statutory factors. 750 ILCS 5/503(d). Those factors include each spouse’s contribution to the acquisition or preservation of property, the value assigned to each spouse, the parties’ economic circumstances, their opportunities to acquire future assets and income, and the tax consequences of the division. Id. § 503(d)(1), (3), (5), (11), (12). 

Generally, a law-firm interest cannot simply be transferred to a nonlawyer spouse. Rule 5.4(d) prevents a lawyer from practicing through a for-profit professional entity if “a nonlawyer owns any interest therein.” Ill. R. Prof’l Conduct (2010) R. 5.4(d)(1). This rule also prohibits a nonlawyer from controlling the lawyer’s professional judgment. Id. R. 5.4(d)(3). 

Thus, the attorney-spouse will often retain the ownership interest while the other spouse receives value through the overall property distribution. The court can award the nonowner spouse other marital assets, order an equalization payment, permit payment in installments, or structure another monetary award consistent with the firm’s governing documents and the parties’ financial circumstances.

In re Marriage of Schlichting illustrates how important it is to divide a business’s value without requiring a transfer that will violate its governing agreement; the appellate court held that the trial court abused its discretion by transferring an LLC membership interest to a nonmember spouse when the operating agreement restricted transfers and provided a valuation procedure for divorce. 2014 IL App (2d) 140158, ¶¶ 47, 60, 68-69. The court held that the nonmember spouse was entitled to “a portion of the cash value of the membership interest, but not an actual membership interest.” Id. ¶¶ 72-73. Schlichting did not involve a law firm, but its reasoning is instructive in showing how professional rules and firm agreements restrict ownership or transfer.

The payment structure needs to account for liquidity. A law firm’s value may be supported by work in process, receivables, or future operating income instead of cash immediately available for distribution. An order that requires full payment at once might force the attorney to withdraw excessive working capital, heavily borrow, or jeopardize the firm’s ability to meet client and payroll obligations.

Still, the payment terms should not require the nonowner spouse to bear unnecessary business risk indefinitely. Proper terms may include defined payment dates, financial reporting, interest, restrictions on extraordinary distributions, or reasonable security that does not interfere with the firm’s professional operations or client property.

Tax consequences must be evaluated, too. An installment obligation, a transfer of other marital property, and the eventual collection of firm receivables can produce differing economic results. Section 503(d) directs the court to consider “the tax consequences of the property division upon the respective economic circumstances of the parties.” 750 ILCS 5/503(d)(12). 

The purpose is not to make the former spouses continuing partners in the law practice but to fairly compensate the nonowner spouse for the marital value while preserving the attorney’s professional independence, the firm’s stability, and the clients’ freedom to select their counsel.

The Bottom Line On Valuing And Dividing A Law Firm In An Illinois Divorce

What is a law firm worth in an Illinois divorce? The answer cannot be determined simply by multiplying revenue by an industry percentage, accepting the income reported on a Schedule K-1, or applying a buy-sell agreement’s formula. The analysis starts with determining the attorney’s ownership interest, the rights and restrictions attached to it, its marital or nonmarital classification, the valuation date, and whether the firm will continue operating. Illinois courts apply a fair-market-value standard. However, there is no exact formula for valuing a professional business. 

Afterwards, the appraiser must normalize the firm’s financial results, determine reasonable compensation for the attorney’s services, value collectible unbilled work and receivables, evaluate retained earnings and capital accounts, and distinguish personal goodwill from enterprise goodwill. 

Valuation is one part of the divorce analysis. The court must translate the marital value into an equitable property division. It must also account for professional-ownership restrictions, governing agreements, other owners’ rights, liquidity, debt, taxes, and the consequences of ordering an immediate equalization payment. The attorney may retain the law-firm interest while the nonowner spouse receives cash, installment payments, other marital property, or another award representing the marital value. 

If you have equity in a law firm or your spouse does, see our Illinois business owner divorce page.

Russell D. Knight is a Chicago divorce and family law attorney who has practiced family law since 2006. He represents clients in complex Illinois divorce matters involving the division of marital assets, law firms and other professional practices, closely held businesses, business valuations, and other difficult-to-value interests. His Chicago practice focuses on Illinois divorce and family law. 

CASES, STATUTES, RULES, AND OTHER SOURCES REFERENCED IN THE LAW-FIRM VALUATION AND DIVORCE IN ILLINOIS ARTICLE

750 ILCS 5/503(a), (b)(1) — Definition And Presumption Of Marital Property

750 ILCS 5/503(a)(1)–(8) — Nonmarital Property, Appreciation, And Income From Nonmarital Property

750 ILCS 5/503(c)(1)–(2) — Commingling And Reimbursement Between Marital And Nonmarital Estates

750 ILCS 5/503(d) — Factors Governing The Division Of Marital Property

750 ILCS 5/503(k)–(l) — Fair-Market-Value Standard, Valuation Date, And Advice From Financial Experts

Illinois Rule of Professional Conduct 1.17 — Sale Of A Law Practice And Client Autonomy

Illinois Rule of Professional Conduct 5.4 — Fee Sharing, Nonlawyer Ownership, And Professional Independence

Illinois Rule of Professional Conduct 5.6 — Restrictions On An Attorney’s Right To Practice

In re Marriage of Zells, 143 Ill. 2d 251 (1991)

In re Marriage of Schneider, 214 Ill. 2d 152 (2005)

In re Marriage of Tietz, 238 Ill. App. 3d 965 (4th Dist. 1992)

In re Marriage of Werries, 247 Ill. App. 3d 639 (4th Dist. 1993)

In re Marriage of Steel, 2011 IL App (2d) 080974

In re Marriage of Gunn, 233 Ill. App. 3d 165 (5th Dist. 1992)

In re Marriage of Schlichting, 2014 IL App (2d) 140158

In re Marriage of Grunsten, 304 Ill. App. 3d 12 (1st Dist. 1999)

Ronald L. Seigneur ed., What It’s Worth: Law Firm Value (2017)

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT LAW-FIRM VALUATION AND DIVORCE IN ILLINOIS

Is An Interest In A Law Firm Marital Property In An Illinois Divorce? An ownership interest acquired during the marriage is typically presumed to be marital property, even when just the attorney’s name appears on the ownership documents. An interest acquired before marriage, by inheritance or gift, or through qualifying nonmarital property may remain nonmarital. However, marital contributions or uncompensated personal effort may create a reimbursement claim. 

How Is A Law Firm Valued In An Illinois Divorce? Illinois courts apply a fair-market-value standard. Depending on the firm and the evidence, an appraiser may consider the asset, income, market, and excess-earnings approaches after identifying the ownership interest, normalizing the financial records, deducting reasonable attorney compensation, and accounting for the firm’s assets, liabilities, and risks. 

Is Goodwill Included In The Value Of A Law Firm? Enterprise goodwill belonging to the continuing firm independently of the attorney can be included if supported by the evidence. Yet personal goodwill attributable to the attorney’s reputation, skills, relationships, and future earning ability is not divisible marital property. 

Are Accounts Receivable And Contingent Fees Included In A Law Firm’s Value? Accounts receivable for services already performed might be included because they are earned assets, but their value should reflect collection risk, expenses, and taxes. Unresolved contingent-fee matters are not the same thing because the attorney may have no present right to payment and the amount may stay speculative. 

Does A Law Firm’s Buy-Sell Agreement Control Its Divorce Value? Not necessarily; a buy-sell agreement may provide persuasive evidence, but the court must decide whether it applies to divorce, what event triggers its formula, and whether it measures fair market value. An agreement that addresses divorce and provides a valuation and buyout procedure can carry greater weight than one limited to disability, retirement, termination, or death.

QR code for this page

Share Article on

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Russell Knight

Russell D. Knight has been practicing family law as a Chicago divorce lawyer since 2006. Russell D. Knight amicably resolves tough cases while remaining a strong advocate for his client’s interests.

More about This Topic

Relevant Articles